Homemade with the Heart • St. Louis, Missouri
A little sweetness for every occasion.
From your morning coffee to a celebration cake, Apple of My Eye Bakery makes the moments you love taste even sweeter.
Daily Bakery Favorites • Sweet Sips • Custom Celebrations
Baked with love,
just for you ♡
"The secret ingredent is love."
A treat for every craving
Find your new favorite
Fresh-baked treats and comforting drinks, made to bring a little joy to your day.
Bakery Favorites
Cinnamon rolls, cakes, cupcakes, and more sweet treats.
Sweet Sips
Espresso drinks, signature lattes, and coffee, hot or iced.
Made for Catering
Custom cakes and crowd-pleasing desserts for your special gathering
The story behind our name
A family receipe.
A leap of faith.
In 2020, Rhonda baked her grandmother Effie's apple pie and shared it with her pastor. His encouragement sparked a holiday launch-and 20 orders arrived overnight. Built on her grandmother's pie and her father's candy apples, the bakery celebrates family, faith, and tradition.
The name reflects Rhonda's belief that each of us is loved and treasured by God.
"The secret ingredient is love."
Made Fresh, Shared Happily
Take a peek at the menu
Browse our daily bakery treats and Sweet Sips, or ask about custom orders for your next gathering.
Daily Menu
Bakery & Sweet Treats
Find a new favorite or come back for the one you already love.
- Cinnamon rolls, muffins & Danish
- Cupcakes, cookies, cake slices
- Parfaits, brownies, and seasonal treats
coffee bar
Sweet Sips
A little something warm-or cool-to pair with your treat.
- Espresso classics & signature lattes
- Regular and decaf drip coffee
- Classic and flavored iced coffee
A Taste of what we make
Fresh from the Kitchen
A few favorites from the bakery. More menu photos coming soon.
Your Idea, Made Sweeter
Have something special in mind?
Special custom orders are always welcome. Tell us what you are celebrating, and we will work with you to create a sweet treat that feels just right.
Let's make it happen
What can we bake for you?
Choose an order from and share a few details. We'll follow up to confirm availability, pricing, and pickup.
Bakery Order
For daily menu items and Sweet Sips.
*Your request is confirmed after bakery follow-up.
Catering Inquiry
For cakes, desserts, and custom celebrations
*Your request is confirmed after bakery follow-up.